The responsibility for statements made at press conferences, during interviews or in written media releases does not rest solely with journalists – individuals and organisations issuing those statements must also be held accountable.
Unlike social media posts, statements made through conventional media can have a far-reaching impact, given the media’s role as an information channel serving the wider public.
However, in today’s communication landscape, media practitioners are increasingly confronted with a challenging issue: sources seeking to withdraw statements they have made, often after facing controversy or public backlash.
Such situations not only test the professional relationship between journalists and news sources but also touch on broader principles of journalism, including editorial independence, reporting integrity and the public’s access to information of public interest.
RETRACT OR NOT?
Should the media retract a report if told to do so by the source or sources of the information?
“No,” said mass communication expert Associate Prof Dr Shahrul Nazmi Sannusi. “No retraction is needed if the report is accurate and reflects the original context of the statement given by the source.”
He said individuals and organisations must take responsibility when their statements spark controversy or attract public criticism, rather than shifting that responsibility to the media, whose role includes providing the public with accurate and credible information.
“Controversy alone is not sufficient grounds for retracting an accurate news report.
“If an individual (news source) criticises an issue or presents certain facts, then asks for the news report to be withdrawn after facing public backlash, the media should not simply comply to protect that person’s image,” he told Bernama recently.
He said this is something news sources should consider carefully before making any public statement.
PUBLIC STATEMENTS COME WITH ACCOUNTABILITY
From the perspective of mass communication, a news source is not merely someone who provides information to journalists but also bears responsibility for the message conveyed, particularly when statements are made voluntarily in the public domain.
Senior lecturer at Universiti Putra Malaysia’s Faculty of Modern Languages and Communication Dr Syed Agil Shekh Alsagoff said individuals who make public statements must be accountable for their content, accuracy and implications.
He said statements delivered at press conferences, during interviews or through official releases generally carry a reasonable expectation that they will be quoted, reported and disseminated to the public, subject to any agreement reached with journalists and the principles of fair reporting.
“The fundamental principle is that anyone who makes a public statement must be accountable for its content, accuracy and implications.
“Statements already given to journalists should not be regarded as something that can be unilaterally withdrawn simply because a source has changed their mind, feels uncomfortable or is concerned about public reaction,” he said.
Elaborating, Syed Agil said source accountability could be viewed from three dimensions: responsibility for the accuracy of statements, implications for society and the importance of maintaining public records.
He said an individual’s statements could influence public perceptions, an organisation’s reputation, confidence in institutions and discussions surrounding policies.
Statements involving matters of public interest, particularly official decisions, the use of public funds, security and the responsibilities of office-holders, also carry significant value for public knowledge.
Therefore, changing one’s mind or feeling uncomfortable with public reactions should not automatically constitute grounds for removing statements that have been accurately reported.
However, he stressed that this principle does not mean the media has absolute freedom to publish any statement without ethical consideration.
“Media organisations remain responsible for ensuring factual accuracy, context, public interest and fairness in reporting,” he said.
EDITORIAL INDEPENDENCE
For media organisations, editorial independence is a fundamental principle that determines the extent to which they can discharge their responsibilities without being influenced by pressure from interested parties.
The media is not merely a channel for relaying statements from sources but also has a responsibility to ensure that every report upholds the principles of accuracy, fairness and journalistic integrity.
Shahrul Nazmi, who is also a Research Fellow at the Institute of Journalism, Media and Communication Studies at Keio University in Tokyo, Japan, said retracting reports merely to maintain professional relationships with sources could undermine media credibility, erode public trust and create conflicts of interest.
He said journalists and editors must uphold the integrity of their media organisations rather than accede to the demands of news sources.
Corrections should be made when a report contains inaccurate facts or misleads readers, but it should not be withdrawn merely because sources are unhappy with the consequences of their statements.
While sources have the right to seek the withdrawal of a news report, such a request does not automatically oblige media organisations to comply, he added
Shahrul Nazmi said one of the challenges facing media organisations is determining whether objections raised by sources are genuinely justified or merely attempts to minimise the negative consequences of statements they had made.
If a source claims that their remarks were misinterpreted, the journalist concerned should review the original recordings and transcripts of the interview and context of the news report before editors decide on the appropriate course of action, he said.
He also said that a news report could be considered for retraction if it contained serious errors that undermined the entire article, involved the dissemination of false information or constituted ethical breaches that could not be rectified through other means.
However, specific errors, such as incorrect names or figures, can be addressed through corrections without withdrawing the entire report.
PROFESSIONAL APPROACH
Meanwhile, Syed Agil said media organisations should also give sources an opportunity to raise objections if quotes were inaccurate, relevant context was omitted or the publication breached agreed interview terms.
“However, the opportunity to provide clarification is not the same as the right to control the original publication,” he said.
He said professional approaches available to media organisations include publishing a follow-up statement, providing additional context that may have been omitted from the initial news report or conducting a follow-up interview to obtain further clarification.
Such approaches would allow sources to present their perspectives without erasing the record of an original report that has been accurately published.
While it is important for journalists to maintain good relationships with their news sources to ensure access to information and facilitate the news-gathering process, such professional bonds should not come at the expense of media organisations’ responsibilities to the public.
If a news report is withdrawn simply because a source has attracted public criticism, such action could raise questions about the media organisation’s independence and integrity.
In this regard, media organisations should have clear procedures for handling requests to retract news reports. The procedures should include reviewing evidence, original recordings and interview agreements, as well as giving sources an opportunity to raise objections for fair consideration.
The final decision, however, should rest with editors, who must exercise independent judgement without pressure from any party, while errors in reports should be corrected or clarified transparently.
BERNAMA provides up-to-date authentic and comprehensive news and information which are disseminated via BERNAMA Wires; www.bernama.com; BERNAMA TV on Astro 502, unifi TV 631 and MYTV 121 channels and BERNAMA Radio on FM93.9 (Klang Valley), FM107.5 (Johor Bahru), FM107.9 (Kota Kinabalu) and FM100.9 (Kuching) frequencies.
Follow us on social media :
Facebook : @bernamaofficial, @bernamatv, @bernamaradio
Twitter : @bernama.com, @BernamaTV, @bernamaradio
Instagram : @bernamaofficial, @bernamatvofficial, @bernamaradioofficial
TikTok : @bernamaofficial